Top Quarterbacks to Start and Sit in Week 1

Introduction

The 2025 NFL fantasy season is finally here and with it comes tough decisions for fantasy managers. One of the most crucial positions to consider is the quarterback, where one wrong start or sit could make or break a week. In Week 1, there are some intriguing matchups and storylines to consider, making it even more challenging to make the right call. Let's take a look at some of the top quarterbacks to start and sit this week.

Key Details

The Jets' rookie quarterback, Justin Fields, will face off against his former Steelers teammates in his debut. Fields has shown flashes of brilliance in the preseason, but can he handle the pressure of a regular-season game? On the other hand, second-year quarterbacks Bo Nix, Drake Maye, and J.J. McCarthy all have favorable matchups, but can they be trusted as starters in their first full seasons as starters?

Impact

Making the right decision at quarterback can be the difference between a win and a loss in fantasy. It's crucial to consider not only the player's talent and matchup but also their experience and surrounding team. Rookie quarterbacks often struggle in their first NFL starts, while experienced veterans may have a slower start to the season. As for the second-year quarterbacks, it's crucial to monitor their progress and chemistry with their new teammates. While it may be tempting to start them